Thursday, September 17, 2015

Reading Between the Stories

         While reading Hemingway’s In Our Time, the one thing that constantly bothered me were the chapters in between the stories. What are these? This topic was brought up in class once or twice, but we never came to a satisfying conclusion on how these chapters contributed to the book as a whole. In my opinion, these “chapters” are too short to be actual chapters or to carry any significant plot, and I struggled with understanding their purpose. At first I just read them without thinking too much, considering them irrelevant to the actual stories. But the fact that In Our Time was written and put together by Hemingway himself meant that there was a specific purpose and motive behind the way he organized the chapters and stories. Not a single chapter was put in the book without a reason. I am still not completely sure on why each chapter was put in the book, but as I thought about these stories, I found that many of them connect a piece of Hemingway himself to the book.

         I think that the first 7 chapters of In Our Time directly correlate with Hemingway’s personal life experience. If you look at the first 7 chapters, they are all related to war one way or another. Hemingway was actually a volunteer ambulance driver for the Italian army in World War I. When I read chapter 3, I immediately thought of World War I as they shot Germans. Hemingway was also injured during the war and spent a lot of time in hospitals. We see that in chapter 6 Nick was hit in the spine and carried to the side out of the war zone. Nick was lying there waiting for a stretcher to come and take him to the hospital. This is a very interesting connection, as it seems Hemingway is being connected to the one character we see consistently throughout the book: Nick. This brings up many thought-provoking questions. Is this connection perhaps more significant than we realize? Why would Hemingway draw such a close link between him and Nick? Could Nick possibly represent Hemingway?

         The first 7 chapters were all related to war, which makes sense when we understand Hemingway’s connection to war. But what was really intriguing for me is that 6 whole chapters, 9-14, were dedicated to bullfighting. Bullfighting? What does this have anything to do with Hemingway or even the stories themselves? Well, we know that Hemingway was a great sportsman, as we read stories of him describing horse racing (My Old Man) and fishing (Big Two-Hearted River). Hemingway obviously enjoys sports. But there was another trend that constantly reappeared throughout the book: masculinity. Hemingway seemed to glorify masculinity and the tough stoic attitude that came along with it. When I think of bullfighting, I think of it as a very “manly” sport. I believe that bullfighting represents the masculine theme that we constantly see throughout the book.


         These are the few ideas and thoughts I’ve come up with for the chapters in In Our Time. However, I still have so many questions regarding these chapters, and feel as though I missed many important connections within them. What are your thoughts? Why did Hemingway put these chapters in between the stories? 

Monday, August 31, 2015

The Things They Carry

               The Things They Carried has a very appropriate beginning as Tim O’Brien starts the book by telling us just that―the things that Jimmy Cross and his men carried. As I read the first two chapters of The Things They Carried, a curious thought crossed my mind: What happened to the things they carried? The phrase “the things they carried” assumes that these were things carried back in the past. However, in the second chapter titled “Love”, I saw evidence that points to show that the things they carried weren’t just left behind in Vietnam. Through the character of Jimmy Cross, I came to realize that they still very much carry the things they carried back during the war. They still carry the ghosts. They still carry their regrets. And in the case of Jimmy Cross, he still carries his fantasies.

              Jimmy Cross carries letters from Martha as the item that characterizes him during the war. I interpreted the letters as a physical representation of what Jimmy Cross really carried: his fantasies. In the first chapter of The Things They Carried, Jimmy was constantly daydreaming about his fantastical love life with Martha, which eventually led to Ted Lavender’s death (or so he believes). Out of grief, Jimmy burns the letters and photos of Martha. Although it may seem as if Jimmy has left behind his fantasies, he has only gotten rid of their physical manifestation. I would argue to say that not only does he continue to carry his fantasies of Martha, but he actually adds another fantasy that he has to carry. Near the end of the first chapter, Jimmy thinks to himself about how he will be a proper leader from now on. How he will discipline himself and his men, making them into the ideal platoon. If you read carefully though, you will notice that this is actually Jimmy Cross daydreaming about what he wants to do, but not actually doing it. The passage never suggests that Jimmy Cross ever fulfilled or accomplished the things he described, but only tells us the plans and thoughts he had in his mind. This is simply another fantasy that Jimmy Cross has added to the load that he already carries.

              But how do we know that he carries these fantasies throughout the war and even afterwards? There is enough evidence in “Love” to confirm that this is true. First off, Jimmy Cross says openly to Tim O’Brien that he loves Martha still, many years after the war. He even encourages Tim to write the stories, hoping that one day Martha would come back for him. Through this, it is clear that Jimmy is continuing to cling onto his fantasy of a love life with Martha. Jimmy also asks Tim to make him out to be the best platoon leader ever. Jimmy is only asking this because he wasn’t the things that he wanted to be. If Jimmy truly was the best platoon leader ever, if he really was brave and handsome and all that, he wouldn’t have had to ask Tim to depict him as such. On top of that, Jimmy asks Tim to not mention something that we don’t know about….or do we? That is a totally different topic though. Anyway, Jimmy asks Tim to leave something out that he doesn’t want others to know about him. Jimmy is trying to get Tim to recreate (through his stories) the fantastical and ideal image of himself that he had carried throughout the years. We can clearly see through this evidence that Jimmy still carries his fantasies of Martha and of himself being the best platoon leader ever.


               What does this show us? Why does it even matter that Jimmy Cross still carries his fantasies with him after the war? All of this is significant because we can understand the life of war veterans through the character of Jimmy Cross. Life doesn’t just return to normal after the war. We have all seen heartwarming and glorious videos of soldiers returning home, and these videos often show soldiers happily reunited with their families. We are often deceived into thinking that all is well and the troubles are over and forgotten after the soldiers return home. However, the truth is that everything isn’t left behind in the war zone. To the contrary, veterans often carry the same things that they carried during the war back to their homes. Veterans still carry their heavy burden of painful memories, disturbing traumas, and searing losses. Through the first two chapters of The Things They Carried, I learned that the things they carried weren’t just left behind in the past, but rather they continue to live on as the things they carry.